Build the Church
Welcome to Build the Church, the podcast designed to equip pastors and ministry leaders with practical strategies, innovative ideas, and actionable insights to grow and lead thriving churches. Hosted by Josh Roberie, each episode explores church leadership, growth strategies, branding, and effective ministry, empowering you to overcome challenges and build a vibrant community of believers. Whether you're planting a new church or leading an established one, Build the Church will provide you with the tools and inspiration to lead with confidence and impact.
Build the Church
How to Create a High-Feedback Culture with Brad and Paige Straarup
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
You want your church team to improve, but you also want people to stay. How do you give honest feedback while strengthening the relationships that make ministry possible?
Brad and Paige Straarup of Spirit Church return to Build the Church to talk with Josh Roberie about creating a healthy feedback culture. They share what they’re learning about leading volunteers, addressing problems early, and balancing accountability with encouragement.
Hear why feedback starts with the pastor’s example, how questions can make correction more productive, and why celebrating wins helps shape your church’s culture. Brad and Paige also explain why high feedback and high retention should be goals you pursue together.
This conversation gives pastors and ministry leaders practical ways to set clear expectations, build trust, and help their teams grow.
CHAPTERS
00:00:00 Building a Healthy Feedback Culture
00:00:23 What You Allow Shapes Your Church Culture
00:03:33 Taking Ownership and Modeling Feedback
00:05:49 Balancing Accountability and Encouragement
00:06:22 Celebrating Wins and Preparing People for Change
00:11:00 Giving Clear Feedback Through Questions
00:12:04 Helping Your Team Receive Feedback
00:13:55 Leading with Humility and Listening First
00:15:25 Correcting Behavior Without Making It Personal
00:16:01 High Feedback and High Retention
00:17:28 Closing Conversation
CONNECT WITH SPIRIT CHURCH
https://www.spiritchurch.co/
FREE RESOURCES FOR PASTORS
https://www.buildthe.church/resources/free-resources
Follow Build the Church for weekly tools and encouragement to help you gain momentum, grow your church, and go the distance in ministry. Share this episode with someone who leads alongside you.
Welcome to the Build the Church podcast, where we help you gain momentum and grow your church and go the distance. I'm Josh Rovery. Today we're going to talk with Pastors Brad and Paige Straw and how to create a high feedback culture that people actually enjoy. There's a difference between having a high feedback culture and one that people actually love and trust you in. And Brad and Paige are going to tell you how to do that in this episode. This is actually part two of our conversation with Brad and Paige. You can go back and listen to part one in last week's episode. Brad and Paige are the pastors of Spirit Church that just celebrated their one-year anniversary in Chandler, Arizona. They bring a wealth of experience to church planning. Brad has a doctorate in myciology. He has served as a creative director, next gen director. He's been over multi-site for churches, and Paige has vast experience in marketing, branding, and creative. You're going to love hearing from them, and I know you're going to grow as a leader. You know, when it comes to your team and building culture, one of the first steps you have to take is making sure people are on the right team. And I want to tell you about a tool that can help you do that. It's called a Your Team. And you can try it free for 30 days right now at your team.church. Your team is a tool that you use in your growth track that allows people to go through a spiritual gift and disk assessment that's branded for your church using a unique URL that helps them be matched to a team at your church based on how God created them. It automatically pairs them based on their spiritual gift and personality. And then it syncs to a dashboard where you can find that information and help them be connected to a team. I would love to have the opportunity to demo this for you and you can try it out at your team.church. Now let's jump into our conversation with Brad and Paige. Paige, you brought up something that I would love to just dig in just a little bit more before we move into the next question. And that is you talked about having a high feedback culture, but you defined it as feedback to you and Brad and your team. So kind of talk up to a pastor that's maybe doesn't have a feedback culture, isn't making time for that, or maybe doesn't even know how to structure that. What does that look like for you guys?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Do you want to you want to share?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think one of the foundations that we've always wanted to talk about when we talk about our culture is that culture is what you create or allow, celebrate or correct. And I think often All right, I'll slow down. Say that again one more time for us. Culture is what you create or allow, celebrate or correct. So I think a lot of pastors are really good at creating culture. Here's who we want to be. Um I think uh with a lot of pastors don't what they don't realize is that you allow culture. So in the meeting the other day, in one of our team meetings the other day, uh someone presented something that wasn't prepared in the way that it needed to, be prepared. So I said nothing. I actually pushed the agenda item on and I just started talking about the next thing because I felt I felt bad for that person. But then I had to go back and just be like, I texted him during the meeting and I said, Hey, can I can I use this as an opportunity for the team? And he was like, Absolutely, we have high trust. And I was like, Hey, can I can I go back to this? I said, if I don't address this, y'all are gonna think that this is what we do. And I was okay, it's okay to do that. It's okay to present at this level. And I was like, and I was like, and it's not. And I and I said, I've already talked to Jared about this. We were texting, but I think sometimes we forget that you can allow culture, but obviously I think where pastors probably struggle the most is actually that correcting, that correcting side. So in every single meeting we build it in, where we're having very direct, honest conversation. And I think we have to go first and we have to allow people to give us feedback first. And I think when we've seen that happen, now all of a sudden we can give them feedback as well. But I think the biggest thing for us is not only correcting it in the meeting, but we'll also correct it in the moments. For example, we have a loadout culture because we have to wear a church plant. And sometimes there's someone that isn't loading out and they're standing and they're chatting. And what I've seen is it can sometimes do more damage to say nothing. And then midweek you're like, hey, can I bring something up? And it feels so serious.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Because you're like, hey, I just feel like you're not loading in, like you're not doing that. And it creates kind of this versus like in the moment addressing it and just be like, hey man, when you do this, this is how it communicates to the team. Can you come with me? Can you actually push this case? Um so I think I'm learning, I'm learning so much that sometimes it's just better to have a couple of things that you go to that you can say, but you address it in the moment.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And I think honestly, this is something we're still really working on as a church plan, as the majority of our team is still dream team. This isn't a huge paid staff where it's like you can lean in because this is their job. So I honestly think this is something the Lord's been teaching us the most in this last year is recognizing that, and we're leaning into it more now because we've realized we've been a little soft. Like even some of our feedback has been a little soft, but it's always going to catch up to you. And it's how you end up with someone on your team where you're looking and you're going, gosh, like uh they're just not the right person. And it's like, okay, but we haven't led them to be the right person. Right.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. No, I've got I'm sorry, I got excited there. I'm wanted to shout you down from the audience. I didn't want you to stop preaching.
SPEAKER_02No, go. I'd like it. So yeah, it's like we've even adopted that phrase, actually. Brad did a vision night for our leaders, and it was just like, we're no longer gonna say, I couldn't get them to, or whatever. They wouldn't, they couldn't. It's no, I have not led them to. And that is has become even a mantra as of a few months ago for our team, our leadership team, to just be like, we don't get to play the blame game or put it on someone else. Like, and it starts with us, and they even see us lead through that. And we've had to get comfortable with giving each other feedback for me, even just receiving feedback in front of everyone. And like it's we're still learning it, but we have to model it and they have to see that. And as we've gotten more comfortable, even giving each other feedback, receiving feedback from everyone, they're like, okay, and they learn they have to be able to take it too. And so we're not getting it perfect, but um, I have not led them to even that phrase has just created even accountability, so it opens the door to more feedback.
SPEAKER_01I think, yeah, I think another thing. So uh for all of us when we're understanding a high feedback culture, obviously there's the culture is what you create or allow, celebrate or correct. A couple other practical things is you have to say it quick, so don't let it linger. But the other thing is you need to make it about the thing and not the person. I think sometimes we we give feedback and it's a personal attack versus like and we're saying something about the person just versus in this moment you weren't at your best. Like, I know that you're better than that. And you're talking about the thing, you're not talking about them, and you're calling them higher versus saying you suck, why did you do that? You're just like, hey, I know you're better than this, why like this is what it needs to be. Um but even what she said, she said that this year what we've noticed is that we were we were softer than we wanted to be. But it's funny, we're talking about this week, this we were talking about it this week actually, and we said that we were actually intentionally soft, and and let me explain what I mean by that. Is we came into a city where we had people that moved later, but when we came into the city, it was us. And we're building brand new relationships with people. And we've always said this that relationships is the bridge that results can come across. So often people are like, I'm gonna have a high feedback culture, and it's like, yeah, but they don't even know you.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you just sound like a jerk at that point.
SPEAKER_00Like they don't even know you, like, right. Feedback has to happen in an environment of encouragement if you're just giving feedback and it's it the feedback needs to be lightning in a rainstorm. There's a rainstorm of encouragement coming down on the person. Yes. Some people just strike you with lightning over and it's like watching Elmer Fudd or something in the Looney Tunes, and he just getting struck over and over and over again. They're like, Why are my people so discouraged? Why aren't they submitted? Why aren't they like, bro, chill out, man? You know? Yes. So uh, but anyway, I'm just so pumped by what you guys are saying. I can't help but to pipe up.
SPEAKER_02But no, no, and positive feedback to your point. Like we say feedback, and we're all even like locked in on like it being critical versus high feedback culture means that we're calling out what like we're celebrating, celebrating, and that's creating culture. We're celebrating, hey, I want to shout out this person because they did they load in, they were working harder than anybody else. And that's actually us in the background going, we've got to get better at everyone, being locked in at Loden. So we're gonna intentionally call out someone who's doing it really well and celebrate that and be like, that's what we want to see. Um and that goes further than just sometimes always just getting on people and just correcting, correcting, correcting. So that's why we celebrate the wins too. And it's like those wins are intentional to something that we've been wanting to see, that's something we're wanting to build culture around.
SPEAKER_01I think I think one more thing, even on this, that that may be helpful because we're learning it, right? So we were intentionally soft for a season so that we could build relationships. And now we have strong relationships, we're a year in, we're coming into year two, and I think sometimes as a leader, you can be like, okay, I've built the relationships, here I come. Lightning bolt. And then and then people are like, What like what just happened? Because that's so different. So for the last month, we have been we've actually been signaling like, hey, coming into year two, um, we had conversations with people like our directors saying, Hey, you're you've been with us a year. Do you want to keep doing this? Do you want to re-up for the next year? And um, they're like, Yes, we want it. And we said, Great. Going into year two, this is what you're gonna feel. And we start narrowrating what we're gonna do, that when we start doing it, they're not like, Man, we just went high feedback all of a sudden. Um, but they know that it's coming, if that makes sense. So I think sometimes it's important with leaders that you narrow rate your leadership, that you're telling people what you're gonna do before you do it. So you say, Hey, I'm gonna do it, and you start doing that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, every every author knows you have to do foreshadowing. And um you if you want people to, if you want to build trust with the people that you're leading, they need to know where you're going. And I think leaders that uh in ministry, you know, we're prophetic or we're in sp inspire people. A lot of pastors are feelers, they feel something, they jerk one way. And it's like my daughter, uh, when she was little and just was able to talk, and we had a curvy road, we leave our our our neighborhood, and she would say, Dad, you're driving me crazy. And she meant it literally and you know, symbolically, because she was going back and forth because I was such an aggressive driver. And a lot of pastors are driving their churches like that, and they're not foreshadowing, they're not giving signs. You need those arrow signs when you make a curve to let you know a curve is coming up. And um, it's it's not that they're bad followers. 90% of the time, it's you're a bad leader. And you know, in it the culture I try to build in my home and with the people that I lead is high accountability, high encouragement. And if you're around me and Amy's the exact same way, we're both firstborns, we're both extroverted D personalities. Uh, she's a little bit more on the on the I. I'm I'm a lot more on the D side of things. And so we won't we won't uh say anything else about that. But you know, it's so we're we're both driven. Uh, but man, we we've learned that you gotta encourage people and you got you gotta love them through it. And you know, I just can't believe the the level of trust you guys have built with your team. It's just amazing. Praise the Lord.
SPEAKER_02Figuring it out. Like it's this truly is even this conversation is like it's something we're having to live out, and it's a lot of it's who we want to be, but even just um it's taking shape over time. But yeah, so it was a timely conversation because we're in the middle of that going into year two, and even that idea of of looking back, I think birthdays, anniversaries, even in your relationships. I was talking to a friend this week. It's like you turn another year older, it makes you so reflective. So I think it we didn't want it to be like lost on us that we're turning a year older. And what do we want to evaluate? What what do we want to change? What need what levers do we need to like push, ramp up? What things do we need to pull back on? Um, even personally, even in our relationship, in our marriage, in our family. So I think um, I feel like this podcast for us is even just like a reflective, uh a giant like reflective moment for us as we're already doing that in real life to just like what are we what are we really building where we it's like it's just the idea of that percentage, just one percent off when you take it 10 years down the road, like it those are super important corrections for those micro minutes for us to be making.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I was gonna say the micro correction thing, Brad, just to you know, pitch back to something you said earlier. You know, it's I think pastors sometimes they make it too big of a deal to pause and tell somebody something. And they and you said two things I want to highlight. One is that people want clarity. That's the number one thing every employee, every team member wants from the person because they want to know, they want to know what's gonna make you happy, and they don't want to wait to get outside those bounds to find out you didn't want them going that direction. I've learned that it you oftentimes you can correct with questions. Say, hey, why are you doing it this way? And they explain it to you and you say, I would love to see you do it this way. And then they they're fine. And they don't even know they got coached or corrected, they're just making an adjustment.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, or sometimes the why that they give, I think helps you have a sneak peek into who they are and the way they think, and you can help them think more the way you're wanting them to think or the way that you think. So totally agree that those questions give you a peek into who they are. And I think to your point too, some of the hardest part about the feedback that's corrective is people say they want it, but when you give it, they don't really want it. And some people don't respond well to feedback. So part of the culture we create is hey, we're gonna be a high feedback culture, but you're gonna like you need to make feedback an enjoyable experience for the person on the other side. So like, and when they don't, we're having to have conversations of, hey, you said you wanted feedback. And when we gave it to you, you're sulking, you're emotional, you're sad, and like you can kind of take time to process, but also did you do you want should I not give you feedback anymore? Is that what this means? Like you so I think with people, people are fickle and we're all emotional beings and have emotions. And and so some of it's learning your people, learning how to give feedback. But those questions can usually get them there to where they're they know they know what you're presenting, they're actually giving you the answer. But then our job is stewarding the different people, different personalities and different sensitivities, but also still leaning in and just saying, hey, if we say we want feedback, then we have to receive it well. Um and we can't go hide in the corner, we don't get to run away um or be hurt. We have to come at least come to the table and be able to process.
SPEAKER_01Josh, you were saying um giving feedback through questions, and I think it's it's so genius. And obviously there's there's moments, right, where you can give feedback that is a statement. Like if someone is greeting at the doors and their gat their back is towards a guest. Like you don't need to ask a series of questions. You can be like, hey, can you turn around for me? That'd be great. Um but but one of the things I think that that is so powerful about you said about asking questions is um you can ask questions as to why did you do it that way. And I think as pastors and as leaders, we also need to have a humility that when we're asking questions, that we have an understanding that we may not be right.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And I think one of the beautiful things about asking questions is sometimes I have said to someone, why would you do it that way? And I really want to say, you should do it this way. But what I say is, Why should you why did you do it that way? And they give me their why and I'm like, Wow, their why is actually better than mine. And and now I don't even need to correct it. I've just asked the question, why did they do it that way? And I'm like, you know what? That's great, keep doing that. Versus imagine if I had come in and I'm like, you should do this, and they're like, no, but this isn't why I do it. And then I'm like, oh, I'm wrong. Now I've made a statement I need to walk back. Versus if I just asked a question and I understood their why, I could say, actually, that's a better idea than what I had. And now we can lead into that space.
SPEAKER_00So I th I I think that you know that's great. And uh, you know, I I I could keep talking about that all day because I love this topic, and I'm glad that this conversation has grown into this. In fact, this is gonna be a two-parter now. We're gonna talk about your church planning story up front, and then I'm gonna do a whole episode on creating a culture of feedback. So you guys are gonna be on two weeks in a row. Thank you. Uh, you know, uh for doing that. I guess you get extra Starbucks gift cards from me.
SPEAKER_02Um I didn't even get an outfit change for two episodes, man.
SPEAKER_00No, you didn't even get to go buy something new. Uh neither did I. So uh, but very, very good. I think the reason why the feedback culture works is listening to you guys, is because you take extreme ownership. You put the weight on you, not on the other person. And anytime you're giving feedback and you're putting all the weight on the other person, um, it doesn't work. And then also the other thing that I feel like I noticed you guys do based on this conversation is you take yourself out of it. And there's nothing worse than like, you know, you disappoint in me, you make it about you, don't make it about you. Totally. Just make it about the behavior and understanding the person so you can coach them to go forward. But uh, I'll let you guys have the last word on this. Anything else you want to add before we we wrap up?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, since this has become part two of a high feedback culture episode, I think I think the last the last word that I'll say is actually something I've heard a lot of podcasts on a high feedback culture. I think something that I haven't heard is there has to be two goals, um, high feedback and high retention. It is it is really easy to create a high feedback culture that drives people away. Big backdoor, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And then you can put you know a gold star on yourself and you're like, I'm a high feedback leader. And it's like, yeah, but no one ever sticks with you. Yeah. And the goal, it's like two sides of a bicycle pedal. It's like we have to have high feedback, but we also have to have high retention. So that's why I was like, relationship is so important before you're just like, we're gonna be a high feedback culture. And it's like there's no trust, there's no understanding, y'all don't even like each other, y'all aren't even hanging out. So even for us, we do a thing once a month called family dinner, and all of our directors come to our house, it's on a Sunday night, we're exhausted, they're exhausted. Um, but we have food and we hang out till 2 a.m. And and we do it, we do it once a month. But those relational environments have been the lifeblood of what we've needed for a high feedback culture because there is so much trust and also so much retention. Like our leaders aren't stepping away because of a high feedback culture, even though church planning is hard. So it has to be high feedback and high retention. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02No, I think I think we said it all.
SPEAKER_00Praise the Lord. Yeah, I mean, this is mission accomplished. You can go to the store now and get you a cup of coffee, get you some beans to grind up. I know what what I'm gonna get you now. I'm gonna send you some my favorite beans here in Birmingham as as a gift for doing two episodes uh with me. And you know, Paige will reap the benefits too, because she'll get that that wonderful coffee her husband makes. So thank you guys so much for being on the podcast. Love you, man. Thank you.
SPEAKER_02Thank you for having us.
SPEAKER_00Well, that was a great, great talk on creating culture in general and also how to create a high feedback culture at your church. I love the way that Brad and Page lead by building trust and allowing feedback to be a two-way street for their church. If you want to find out more about Brad and Page, you can go to their church's website at spiritchurch.co. And you can follow them at social media at BradTrup and at PageTrup. You can spell their last name S-T-R-K-A-R-U-P. And links will be in the show notes. If you haven't done so yet, I'd love for you to go and rate this podcast wherever you listen to podcasts and subscribe. It's the best thing that you can do to help get this show in front of more people, and I greatly appreciate you taking just a moment to do that. This episode is brought to you by your team.church. It's a digital assessment tool that's framed for your church with a unique URL that brings your volunteers to an assessment that automatically matches them to a team based on how God has designed us. And as always, thank you for joining me today. I can't wait for you to be with us next time until they keep leaving and believing strong.